What is Asylum Firm Resettlement?

If you have come to the U.S. seeking protection from persecution but have “firmly resettled” in a third country, you are ineligible for protections under asylum , withholding of removal, and Convention Against Torture.

However, because what constitutes “firm resettlement” is complex, it is important for you to consult an experienced immigration attorney before moving forward.

The definitions and bars of firm resettlement differ slightly for asylum and refugee cases. In both instances, the firm resettlement must have occurred prior to your admission to, or arrival in the U.S. and you must have received an offer of permanent resident status, citizenship, or other type of permanent resettlement from that country. The definitions differ in a refugee must have traveled to and entered that country as a consequence of fleeing persecution.

There are exceptions to the firm resettlement bar that allow an applicant to apply for refugee or asylum status. Although these vary slightly between refugee status and asylum status, there are two main exceptions available to applicants. The first, applying to both refugee and asylum applicants, is the conditions of the third country were so restrictive that they were not in fact firmly resettled. Restrictive conditions which might establish an exception to the firm resettlement bar include:

  • Formal government policy limiting the rights of non-citizen residents;
  • Inability of government to ensure that individuals receive benefits;
  • Withholding of refugee’s travel documentation by the government; or
  • Threat or harm by a persecutor in the country of resettlement.

The second exemption applies only to asylum applicants and states that if no significant ties were made to the third country in consideration, then firm resettlement was not established. In order for an applicant to prove they had no significant ties they must establish that:

  • Entry into the country was a necessary consequence of fleeing persecution;
  • They remained only as long as was necessary to arrange onward travel; or
  • They did not establish significant ties in that country.

The issue of firm resettlement is complex and often left to the discretion of the government official reviewing your case. If you wish to receive protections under asylum, withholding of removal, and Convention Against Torture and believe your case is an exception to the firm resettlement bar, then consulting an immigration attorney with experience in similar cases is in your best interest.